Seems to me, as an observer with a loud voice in the CBL1 stand, that every single fan should take responsibility for their singing and just get on with it in their own way.
As for the singing on your own in an area and people tutting, tough luck to the tutters, they used to do it round near me. Now they join in and I reckon that’s because I just ignored them and persevered.
Of course I’m lucky because I still remember the classics and start them on my own…. I can’t sing, was once told by my stepmother I was tone deaf but I’m old enough and ugly enough, as they say, to just do what I want these days.
SING, SHOUT, YELL for the lads you lazy so and so’s who don’t. The rest of us, keep the faith lads and lasses it will come eventually. But please not drums, no ‘ultras’ or whatever they’re called. Make it everyone together not one person at the front singing! Yes ‘conduct’ them as if they’re a LOUD choir but let them make the noise.
Sorry if that’s controversial or not in keeping with everyone. Just my humble (daft) opinion. :-) :-)