joe hart

Status
Not open for further replies.
Proelia said:
3rdlanarkblue said:
I loved Joe Corrigan and Joe Hart is the best we've had since then by a country mile. He will have ups and downs and he has room to improve a few things but he is ten times better than Shay Given was.
Click to expand...

At his peak shay is one of the premier leagues finest goalies ever
Click to expand...

For some reason the scousers hate him. They used to call him "Hollywood" and reckoned he looked great at shot stopping and making the odd brilliant save, but the rest of his game wasn't up to much. Rags didn't like him either. Nothing like the hate they have for Joe though.
Tbf, Shay used to get a fair bit of stick on here because he wouldn't come for crosses and always relied on his reflexes instead of trying to command his area. Once he got a little older and his reflexes started slowing down, his game dipped markedly. Great keeper, but a level below Schmeichel, Seaman etc.
 
Kun Aguero said:
Where's the haters today? that save from Smalling(I think!) was top class.
Click to expand...

I was trying to get the East Stand to chant England's No. 1 and I was on my own. It was Level 2!!
 
Was watching the match last night and you can tell our new goalkeeping coach has had a huge influence in Harts distribution. Kicking seems to have improved and hes started throwing it out long (one which was perfect to Negredo).

The signs are looking good, lets hope he keeps that up.
 
3rdlanarkblue said:
I loved Joe Corrigan and Joe Hart is the best we've had since then by a country mile. He will have ups and downs and he has room to improve a few things but he is ten times better than Shay Given was.
Click to expand...
I think Hart is one of the best goalies we've had but not as good as Coton or even Williams. Hart has got the advantage of playing in a great side with a good defence in front of him too.
 
nobody can eat fifty eggs said:
3rdlanarkblue said:
I loved Joe Corrigan and Joe Hart is the best we've had since then by a country mile. He will have ups and downs and he has room to improve a few things but he is ten times better than Shay Given was.
Click to expand...
I think Hart is one of the best goalies we've had but not as good as Coton or even Williams. Hart has got the advantage of playing in a great side with a good defence in front of him too.
Click to expand...


Not as good as Williams...wow
 
Nelly's Left Foot said:
nobody can eat fifty eggs said:
3rdlanarkblue said:
I loved Joe Corrigan and Joe Hart is the best we've had since then by a country mile. He will have ups and downs and he has room to improve a few things but he is ten times better than Shay Given was.
Click to expand...
I think Hart is one of the best goalies we've had but not as good as Coton or even Williams. Hart has got the advantage of playing in a great side with a good defence in front of him too.
Click to expand...


Not as good as Williams...wow
Click to expand...
Williams was a top goalie and very underrated in an era when there was plenty of great keepers around.
Did you not rate him or are you too young to have watched him in his prime?
 
nobody can eat fifty eggs said:
Nelly's Left Foot said:
nobody can eat fifty eggs said:
I think Hart is one of the best goalies we've had but not as good as Coton or even Williams. Hart has got the advantage of playing in a great side with a good defence in front of him too.
Click to expand...


Not as good as Williams...wow
Click to expand...
Williams was a top goalie and very underrated in an era when there was plenty of great keepers around.
Did you not rate him or are you too young to have watched him in his prime?
Click to expand...

He is great, just need an immage
Joe need to be involved in game more by verbally commanding deffence, screeming, waving, positioning defenders, building up the tension over and over again so deffence will be always ready. Need more freedom to be real "defense commander", saving the goal is not sufficent to take him to legend.
 
Len Rum said:
Poor positioning for goals two and three today but he won't be dropped. He'll need to be at his best on Wednesday.
Click to expand...

His positioning behind the wall for the free kick baffled me a bit. For Rooney's free kicks last week he stood away from the wall so he could see the direction of the ball and very nearly saved the goal. Today he had no chance of seeing the ball until it was too late.
 
Len Rum said:
Poor positioning for goals two and three today but he won't be dropped. He'll need to be at his best on Wednesday.
Click to expand...

didn't he just put a run of 5/6 clean sheets together? not going to criticise Joe for today, theres no way he should have been put in the situation for the third, and sometimes free kicks are just that good they deserve a goal
 
Len Rum said:
Poor positioning for goals two and three today but he won't be dropped. He'll need to be at his best on Wednesday.
Click to expand...

I thought he was poor for all three to be honest. I hope we make a statement of intent and "drop" him for Wednesday.

But hang on he'll then just go crying to the directors about how unfairly he's been treated and get the manager sacked. That can't ever happen at City?....can it?
 
he should have been able to get close to that freekick.

as a goalkeeper you should stand in the middle of your goal, or close to the middle. that way, it will have to be a very good shot to beat you.

casillas in jan please.
 
BosnianDragon said:
nobody can eat fifty eggs said:
Nelly's Left Foot said:
Not as good as Williams...wow
Click to expand...
Williams was a top goalie and very underrated in an era when there was plenty of great keepers around.
Did you not rate him or are you too young to have watched him in his prime?
Click to expand...

He is great, just need an immage
Joe need to be involved in game more by verbally commanding deffence, screeming, waving, positioning defenders, building up the tension over and over again so deffence will be always ready. Need more freedom to be real "defense commander", saving the goal is not sufficent to take him to legend.
Click to expand...

Well, that's sorted then.
 
ban-mcfc said:
he should have been able to get close to that freekick.

as a goalkeeper you should stand in the middle of your goal, or close to the middle. that way, it will have to be a very good shot to beat you.

casillas in jan please.
Click to expand...

There's a reason he doesn't play for Madrid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top